Traditional surrogacy is one of the earliest forms of assisted reproduction, but also one of the most legally and emotionally complex surrogacy types.
In traditional surrogacy, the surrogate uses her own egg, meaning she is both the genetic and gestational mother of the child.
This model once made surrogacy possible before IVF was widespread. However, it’s now restricted in some countries because of legal risks related to parental rights, consent withdrawal, and ethical concerns.
How Traditional Surrogacy Works
%201%20(1).jpg)
In traditional surrogacy, conception occurs through artificial insemination or intrauterine insemination (IUI) using:
-
The intended father’s sperm, or
-
Donor sperm when the intended father cannot contribute.
-
Surrogate’s egg is used, which means that surrogate mother is biologically related to the baby
This biological connection means that the surrogate has parental rights unless they are legally terminated or transferred after birth through adoption or a court order.
Key Legal and Ethical Considerations
Unlike gestational surrogacy, traditional surrogacy blurs the line between biological and intended parenthood and that’s where most of the complexity begins.
Imagine a woman who decides to help another couple by carrying a baby created with her own egg. During pregnancy, she feels the kicks, hears the heartbeat, and forms a natural connection with the child. After birth, the law in many countries recognizes her as the baby’s legal mother, because she is both the genetic and the birth mother.
For the intended parents, this can be emotionally and legally challenging. In some jurisdictions, the surrogate must formally give up her parental rights after the birth, but the law also allows her to change her mind before that happens.
It’s rare, but cases like these have made courts cautious, and they’re a big reason why most countries now limit or prohibit traditional surrogacy altogether.
Even when everyone’s intentions are good, the legal path forward is rarely simple. Parental rights often need to be transferred through adoption or a post-birth parental order, a process that can take months. Meanwhile, the intended parents might not have full parental authority over their own newborn.
Ethically, many specialists now agree that the emotional and biological bonds created in traditional surrogacy can place too much weight on the surrogate’s ability to separate after birth.
That’s why today, gestational surrogacy, where the surrogate is not genetically related to the child, is viewed as the safer, clearer, and more respectful framework for everyone involved.
Comparison: Traditional vs. Gestational vs. Hybrid Surrogacy
Traditional Surrogacy
Egg Source
Surrogate’s own egg
Genetic Link to Surrogate
Yes
Method Used
Insemination (IUI/AI)
Legal Parent at Birth
Surrogate
Legal Risk
High
Availability
Banned or limited in most countries
Best For
Very limited situations where law permits
Egg Source
Intended parent’s or donor egg
Genetic Link to Surrogate
No
Method Used
IVF and embryo transfer
Legal Parent at Birth
Intended parents (in regulated programs)
Legal Risk
Low
Availability
Regulated in some countries
Best For
Most intended parents
Egg Source
Intended parent’s or donor egg created in one country and transferred in another
Genetic Link to Surrogate
None (surrogate only carries the embryo)
Method Used
IVF and embryo transfer, often across multiple countries
Legal Parent at Birth
Intended parents, depending on legal frameworks in both jurisdictions
Legal Risk
Variable – depends on coordination between jurisdictions, but mitigated with expert legal counsel
Availability
Growing practice in international programs; legality depends on countries involved
Best For
Intended parents needing to combine destinations for cost, legal, or medical optimization (e.g., LGBTQIA+, HIV-positive, or single parents)
Comparison: Traditional vs. Gestational vs. Hybrid Surrogacy
Feature | Traditional Surrogacy | Gestational Surrogacy | Hybrid Surrogacy |
|---|---|---|---|
Egg Source | Surrogate's own egg | Intended parent's or donor egg | Intended parent's or donor egg created in one country and transferred in another |
Genetic Link to Surrogate | Yes | No | None (surrogate only carries the embryo) |
Method Used | Insemination (IUI/AI) | IVF and embryo transfer | IVF and embryo transfer, often across multiple countries |
Legal Parent at Birth | Surrogate | Intended parents (in regulated programs) | Intended parents, depending on legal frameworks in both jurisdictions |
Legal Risk | High | Low | Variable - depends on coordination between jurisdictions, but mitigated with expert legal counsel |
Availability | Banned or limited in most countries | Regulated in some countries | Growing practice in international programs; legality depends on countries involved |
Best For | Very limited situations where law permits | Most intended parents | Intended parents needing to combine destinations for cost, legal, or medical optimization (e.g., LGBTQIA+, HIV-positive, or single parents) |
Why Traditional Surrogacy Is Rare Today
Traditional surrogacy has deep historical roots, dating back to biblical times. One of the earliest recorded examples appears in the Book of Genesis, where Sarai (Sarah), unable to conceive, asked her maid Hagar to bear a child with her husband Abraham—a story that illustrates both the hope and the emotional complexity that can accompany such arrangements.
Traditional surrogacy was once the only way for intended parents to build a family through another woman’s help. But as medicine, law, and ethics evolved, it became clear that this approach often created more challenges than solutions.
Even today, informal traditional surrogacy still happens in surprising ways. I was genuinely shocked to hear a real-life story from the UK: during a casual conversation at a pub, a man offered that his wife could act as a surrogate for his friend. The friend provided sperm in a syringe, conception occurred at home, and the surrogate gave birth. Today, the two families remain friends—and while their story has a positive outcome, it highlights how some people continue to rely on informal, unregulated arrangements that carry significant emotional and legal risks.
Because the surrogate is genetically related to the baby, the emotional and legal boundaries can blur. Even when all parties begin with trust and goodwill, the deep biological connection can lead to painful disputes about parental rights. Courts in several countries have seen difficult cases where a surrogate changed her mind or where the intended parents faced delays in being recognized as the legal parents.
At the same time, advances in IVF technology have transformed what’s possible. Gestational surrogacy, where the surrogate carries an embryo created from the intended parents’ or donors’ genetic material, separates biology from pregnancy. This clarity protects everyone involved and removes much of the emotional risk that traditional surrogacy once carried.
For these reasons, international reproductive health bodies such as the World Health Organization (WHO), the European Society of Human Reproduction and Embryology (ESHRE), and the American Society for Reproductive Medicine (ASRM) now regard gestational surrogacy as the most ethical and secure model when properly regulated.
Today, traditional surrogacy survives only in rare, altruistic arrangements. Often among family members or within domestic settings where all parties share a strong personal bond.
Cross-border traditional surrogacy programs have virtually disappeared, replaced by safer and more clearly defined gestational frameworks that better protect everyone’s rights and emotions.
How The Surrogacy Insider Can Help
If you’re considering traditional surrogacy, you deserve clear, honest information, not vague promises or outdated advice. My name is Olga Pysana, and as an independent surrogacy consultant, my role is to help you understand what’s truly possible, what’s risky, and what safer paths may exist for your family.
Together, we’ll look at the real-world implications of traditional surrogacy, from emotional and legal uncertainties to the shifting global regulations that make this route increasingly rare. I’ll also walk you through gestational and hybrid surrogacy options, explaining how these modern models can provide greater legal protection, emotional stability, and control throughout your journey.
Every family’s situation is different, shaped by citizenship, medical history, personal values, and financial considerations. My goal is to help you see the full picture and choose the path that aligns with your circumstances, not someone else’s program.
If you’d like to talk through your surrogacy process in a safe, judgment-free space, I invite you to book a FREE30-minute Discovery Call. It’s a chance to ask questions, gain clarity, and start mapping a path to parenthood that feels secure, ethical, and achievable for you.
FAQs
Traditional surrogacy is when the surrogate uses her own egg to conceive a baby for the intended parents, usually through insemination with the intended father’s or donor’s sperm. This means she is both the genetic and birth mother of the child.
The process typically involves:
-
A legal agreement between the surrogate and intended parents.
-
Insemination using the surrogate’s own egg and the intended father’s sperm.
-
The surrogate carries the pregnancy and gives birth.
After birth, parental rights are transferred to the intended parents through a court order or adoption, depending on local laws.
-
In traditional surrogacy, the surrogate provides her own egg, she is genetically related to the baby.
In gestational surrogacy, an embryo created via IVF is transferred to the surrogate’s uterus, so she has no genetic connection to the child. This makes gestational surrogacy legally and emotionally safer.Traditional surrogacy uses the surrogate’s own egg and occurs in one country with high legal risk, while hybrid surrogacy is a multi-country, gestational process that combines the best legal, medical, and cost advantages through coordinated international planning.
The surrogate herself provides the egg, which is why she is considered the biological mother. This genetic connection is the key difference between traditional and gestational surrogacy.
Yes, donor sperm can be used if the intended father cannot provide sperm. However, donor eggs are not part of traditional surrogacy because the surrogate’s own egg is always used.
Traditional surrogacy is restricted or banned in most countries due to its emotional and legal complexity. It may still be allowed under specific conditions in some U.S. states, the U.K. (on an altruistic basis), and select domestic arrangements elsewhere.
It is legally permitted, often only on an altruistic basis, in a few regions such as:
-
The United Kingdom (under strict non-commercial conditions)
-
Some U.S. states (depending on local laws)
-
Canada, under the altruistic model
-
Certain domestic arrangements in countries where laws are not explicitly prohibitive
International traditional surrogacy is less recognized or supported by clinics or agencies today.
-
Because it creates a genetic tie between the surrogate and the child, which increases emotional attachment and potential custody disputes. Legal systems often struggle to resolve these cases fairly, leading most countries to adopt gestational surrogacy as the safer alternative.
At birth, the surrogate is typically recognized as the legal mother, since she gave birth and contributed her egg. The intended parents can usually obtain legal parenthood only through adoption or a parental order after birth.
Yes, in some jurisdictions she can. Because she is the biological mother, many laws allow her the right to withdraw consent before parentage is legally transferred. This is one of the main risks of traditional surrogacy.
Parenthood is usually established through a court process, such as adoption or a parental order. Both the surrogate and her partner (if she has one) must consent before parental rights can be legally transferred.
Ethical debates focus on emotional attachment, potential exploitation, and coercion. Because the surrogate is genetically linked to the baby, separating biological and emotional bonds can be deeply complex, even with good intentions on all sides.
A detailed surrogacy agreement is essential. It should outline roles, expectations, medical consent, and financial terms. However, in some countries (like the UK), these agreements are not legally enforceable, they serve as guidance rather than legal protection.
Costs vary by country, but traditional surrogacy is usually less expensive than gestational surrogacy because IVF is not required. In countries where it’s legal, total costs can range from $30,000 to $70,000 USD, depending on medical, legal, and travel factors.
In most countries that allow traditional surrogacy, only altruistic reimbursement is permitted — covering reasonable expenses like medical care, travel, and maternity clothing. Direct payment for carrying the child is generally prohibited.
It can cost 30–50% less because IVF and lab procedures aren’t required. However, the potential legal and emotional risks often outweigh the financial savings.
For intended parents, the main risk is loss of custody if the surrogate changes her mind. For surrogates, emotional attachment and regret can occur after birth. Both parties face legal uncertainty unless the process is tightly regulated.
Some families turn to traditional surrogacy when IVF is unavailable or unaffordable, or when the arrangement is between trusted relatives or close friends. In these intimate, altruistic cases, the emotional bond and trust can make the arrangement feel meaningful, though it still carries legal risks.
Safer and more secure alternatives to traditional surrogacy are gestational surrogacy, where the surrogate has no genetic link to the child, and hybrid surrogacy, which strategically combines destinations with strong legal and medical frameworks to minimize risk.
Stay Connected With Me
You don’t have to walk this journey alone. Stay in touch and find support:
-
Join my Facebook Community - meet other LGBTQIA+ intended parents and learn from shared experiences.
-
Follow me on Instagram (@thesurrogacyinsider) - I share tips, stories, and behind-the-scenes guidance.
-
Use the Contact Form - no question is too small, and I personally reply.
Together, we’ll create a roadmap that fits your goals and values. Let’s turn the dream of parenthood into reality — on your terms, with independent guidance you can trust.
